Quality of Earnings: What Is the Company’s Sustainable EBITDA?
Executive Summary
A company seeking institutional capital will commonly lead with a reported EBITDA figure and a management-adjusted number that is higher. The difference may appear modest when presented as a list of add-backs. It can become material when the same figure is used to calculate enterprise value, determine leverage, size a debt facility, negotiate covenant headroom or assess the equity required to complete a transaction. The central question is therefore not how much EBITDA management can add back. It is what the business can reasonably be expected to earn from its continuing operations, on a basis that an independent investor or lender can reconstruct and defend.
A quality-of-earnings analysis, usually referred to as a QoE review, examines the reliability and continuing relevance of the earnings reported in a company’s historical financial information. It tests the composition of revenue, the completeness and classification of costs, the consistency of accounting policies, the adequacy of accruals and reserves, the effect of owner and related-party arrangements, and changes in the customer base or operating perimeter. The result is not necessarily an increase in EBITDA. A properly conducted review may increase, decrease or leave reported EBITDA unchanged. It may also conclude that the historical figure is not an appropriate basis for underwriting without substantial qualification.
Three figures must be kept separate. Reported EBITDA is derived from the company’s historical accounting records using a stated calculation. Diligence-adjusted historical EBITDA is the reported figure corrected for adjustments that are supported by evidence and relate to the historical period. Pro forma run-rate EBITDA reflects identifiable changes to the business that have occurred, or have become sufficiently established, after the historical period, such as a completed acquisition, disposal, implemented cost reduction or confirmed customer loss. A forecast of future growth, a pipeline opportunity or an unimplemented cost-saving plan is not historical EBITDA and should not be presented as though it were.
The distinction is not semantic. Consider a hypothetical precision-manufacturing business reporting USD 8.0 million of EBITDA. Management presents USD 9.85 million after adding back the full remuneration of its owner-manager, an annual systems programme and anticipated staff savings. A detailed review identifies some legitimate adjustments, but also finds premature revenue recognition, unrecorded rebates, insufficient warranty and inventory reserves, and routine maintenance costs capitalised as assets. The resulting diligence-adjusted historical EBITDA is USD 7.63 million. A subsequent loss of a material customer, partly offset by a cost reduction that has actually been implemented, takes the illustrative pro forma run rate to USD 6.36 million. The difference from management’s presentation is USD 3.49 million of annual EBITDA.
At an assumed 6.0x EBITDA valuation multiple, that difference represents USD 20.94 million of indicated enterprise value. At an assumed 4.0x gross leverage ratio, it represents USD 13.96 million of mechanical debt-sizing difference. Neither multiple is a market benchmark, valuation conclusion or financing commitment. The calculations simply show why an earnings adjustment that appears technical in an accounting schedule can become a major transaction issue.
A QoE review is not an audit, a forecast, a valuation opinion or a lender’s credit approval. It is a disciplined translation of historical financial information into a more reliable earnings base for transaction analysis. It must be followed by consideration of working capital, maintenance capital expenditure, cash taxes, debt-like obligations and cash conversion. EBITDA is an important underwriting input, but the ability to service debt ultimately depends on cash generated after the business funds the requirements of its operations.
For a promoter, the practical lesson is that a credible financing presentation begins with a reconciled and evidenced earnings base, not the highest adjusted number management can produce. For an investor or lender, the discipline is to identify which earnings are repeatable, which adjustments are justified, which liabilities or costs have been omitted, and which assumptions belong in a forecast rather than in historical earnings. In either case, the quality of the analysis affects the price, leverage, capital structure and execution risk of the transaction.
1. The Question Behind a Quality-of-Earnings Review
1.1 Reported profitability is not automatically sustainable profitability
A set of audited accounts can be correctly prepared under the applicable accounting framework and still be an incomplete guide to the earnings that a buyer or lender should use in a transaction. Financial statements are prepared for a defined reporting period and according to accounting recognition and measurement requirements. They are not ordinarily designed to answer every transaction-specific question about maintainable earnings, the cost base that will continue after a change of ownership, the consequences of a customer contract ending, or the level of earnings available to support a new debt structure.
A QoE review addresses those questions by testing the financial record against the economic activity that produced it. A reported sale is examined against the underlying contract, performance obligation, delivery or service evidence, customer acceptance provisions, invoice, credit notes and subsequent cash receipt. A claimed expense add-back is examined against the invoice, general-ledger entry, historical recurrence, the reason the cost arose, whether it has ceased, and whether a replacement cost will be required. A provision is considered against the obligation that gave rise to it and the evidence available about expected claims or settlement costs. The review is not complete when the adjustment is entered in a spreadsheet. The adjustment must be understood, evidenced and connected to the company’s continuing operating model.
The Association of Insolvency & Restructuring Advisors’ 2024 discussion of QoE analysis identifies five broad classes of adjustment: discretionary expenses; unusual or non-recurring income and expenses; timing or accounting-policy adjustments; major customer wins and losses; and merger-and-acquisition run-rate adjustments. It also emphasises the connection between earnings, working capital and capital expenditure. Those categories provide a useful analytical framework, but they are not a universal accounting standard or a substitute for transaction-specific judgement. [1]
1.2 Four different exercises that should not be confused
An audit, a QoE review, a forecast and a valuation may use some of the same financial information, but they answer different questions.
| Exercise | Principal question | What it does not establish |
|---|---|---|
| Statutory audit or financial-statement audit | Have the historical financial statements been audited under the applicable auditing standards, and what opinion has the auditor expressed? | It does not determine the EBITDA a particular lender will recognise, nor does it guarantee that past earnings will continue. |
| Quality-of-earnings review | What do the historical results indicate about ongoing earnings after testing revenue, costs, accounting, ownership arrangements and operational changes? | It is not an audit opinion, assurance that fraud or error is absent, or a guarantee of future performance. |
| Forecast or business plan | What could the company earn under specified assumptions about revenue, margins, costs, investment and execution? | It does not convert an unimplemented plan, unsigned opportunity or expected synergy into historical earnings. |
| Valuation or credit underwriting | What value or amount of capital may be justified after considering the earnings base, risk, cash flow, capital structure and relevant transaction terms? | It is not determined by EBITDA alone and does not follow mechanically from a QoE adjustment. |
A QoE review is best understood as a bridge between historical accounting information and the assumptions used in a valuation or financing model. The bridge can be useful to both the buyer and the seller. A buyer uses it to avoid paying for earnings that are not durable. A seller uses it to identify weaknesses before a process begins and to substantiate earnings that may otherwise be discounted because the underlying records are difficult to interpret. The commercial value lies in a more reliable understanding of the business, not in producing a larger adjusted EBITDA number. [1]
1.3 EBITDA is not a universally defined accounting subtotal
EBITDA is commonly calculated as earnings before interest, income taxes, depreciation and amortisation. Depending on the starting point used, the calculation may be built upwards from profit after tax or downwards from operating profit. A simple bridge from profit after tax is:
EBITDA = Profit after tax + income tax expense + net finance costs + depreciation + amortisation
The bridge must be adjusted for the actual composition of the financial statements. For example, material finance income, non-operating gains, discontinued operations, non-controlling interests, impairment charges or unusual items may require separate identification. The calculation should not be presented as a universal formula that overrides the company’s accounting framework or the definition in a financing agreement.
EBITDA is not a defined subtotal under IFRS Accounting Standards. It is a non-IFRS performance measure, and the treatment of particular items can vary across companies, reporting contexts and financing documents. The United States Securities and Exchange Commission’s guidance on non-GAAP financial measures, for example, warns that excluding normal, recurring cash operating expenses necessary to operate a business may result in a misleading measure in the relevant US reporting context. It also highlights the risk of inconsistent treatment between periods and of labels that do not accurately describe the measure. Those interpretations apply to SEC registrants and are not a global rulebook for private-company finance, but the underlying discipline is relevant to any transaction: the measure must be described, reconciled and applied consistently. [2]
The term sustainable EBITDA is used in this article as an analytical description of the earnings base that appears supportable from the available evidence and the operating model expected to continue. It is not a separate accounting measure prescribed by IFRS, US GAAP or a single global lending standard. A lender may ultimately use a separately negotiated definition of EBITDA in its credit agreement. That contractual figure may differ from an independent QoE conclusion.
2. Establishing the Historical EBITDA Baseline
2.1 Start with a reconciled income statement
The first task is to establish the earnings figure before adjustments. The company should not begin with a management presentation that contains a single EBITDA number but no reconciliation to the accounting records. The calculation should be traceable to the audited financial statements, monthly management accounts, trial balance and general ledger, with differences between those records identified and explained.
The following illustration uses a hypothetical industrial business, Aster Precision Components Ltd. All amounts are in USD millions unless otherwise stated. Aster manufactures precision components for industrial equipment and automotive customers. It has an established factory, a mix of repeat customer contracts and purchase orders, and is considering an expansion and refinancing transaction.
| Illustrative historical income statement | USD million |
|---|---|
| Revenue | 60.00 |
| Cost of goods sold | (41.00) |
| Gross profit | 19.00 |
| Selling, general and administrative expenses, before depreciation and amortisation | (11.00) |
| EBITDA | 8.00 |
| Depreciation | (1.30) |
| Amortisation | (0.50) |
| Operating profit (EBIT) | 6.20 |
| Net finance costs | (1.00) |
| Profit before tax | 5.20 |
| Income tax expense | (1.40) |
| Profit after tax | 3.80 |
Aster’s reported EBITDA margin is calculated as follows:
EBITDA margin = EBITDA / Revenue
USD 8.00m / USD 60.00m = 13.33%
The margin is useful as an initial point of comparison, but it is not evidence by itself that the earnings are sustainable. A 13.33% margin may be attractive in one manufacturing segment and weak in another. It may also be temporarily inflated by revenue recognised ahead of performance, deferred maintenance, inadequate warranty accruals or costs capitalised rather than expensed. The ratio tells the analyst where to investigate; it does not settle the investigation.
The same EBITDA can be reconciled from profit after tax:
| Bridge from profit after tax | USD million |
|---|---|
| Profit after tax | 3.80 |
| Add: income tax expense | 1.40 |
| Add: net finance costs | 1.00 |
| Add: depreciation | 1.30 |
| Add: amortisation | 0.50 |
| Reported EBITDA | 8.00 |
This reconciliation is a control. If management’s EBITDA schedule does not tie to the accounting records, the analyst first needs to identify the difference. Possible causes include inconsistent treatment of finance income, foreign-exchange gains and losses, lease expenses, exceptional items, depreciation, amortisation or non-operating income. It is premature to discuss add-backs while the historical starting point remains unresolved.
2.2 Compare periods on a like-for-like basis
The review should normally examine several historical periods, often including the last three financial years and the latest trailing twelve months (LTM), where the underlying data is reliable. The appropriate period depends on the nature of the business. A seasonal manufacturer, project contractor or exporter may require monthly or quarterly analysis because a full-year result can conceal a temporary working-capital peak, a production interruption or a particularly strong delivery quarter.
The analyst should prepare a consistent series showing revenue, gross profit, EBITDA, EBITDA margin, depreciation, capital expenditure, working capital and significant non-recurring items. The series should explain whether earnings growth came from increased volume, pricing, product mix, improved utilisation, lower input costs, acquisitions or accounting changes. Growth that arises from price increases or a single customer order may have a different risk profile from growth arising from a diversified base of repeat orders.
Trailing-twelve-month calculations require particular care. A simple addition of the latest twelve monthly management accounts can be unreliable where the books are not closed consistently, where year-end accruals are incomplete, or where monthly reporting uses accounting treatments that differ from the audited accounts. The LTM number should reconcile to the latest reported financial period and explain any normalising journal entries made to produce it.
A run-rate calculation is also not the same as an LTM calculation. A run-rate figure may annualise the latest month or quarter, but that approach is only credible where the period is representative. Annualising a strong month after a one-off contract delivery, a temporary raw-material price benefit or a seasonal peak can materially overstate the recurring earnings base. Annualising a weak month affected by planned maintenance or a temporary shutdown can understate it. The analyst should explain the event that makes the selected period representative.
2.3 Understand the accounting framework before changing the numbers
A global transaction may involve companies reporting under IFRS Accounting Standards, US GAAP, UK-adopted international accounting standards or local accounting requirements. The relevant framework should be identified before the analyst makes an adjustment. Different accounting policies can affect revenue timing, inventory costing, lease presentation, provisions, capitalisation and other areas that influence EBITDA.
The purpose of a QoE review is not to replace the statutory accounts with an accounting policy preferred by the buyer. It is to understand whether the accounting treatment is appropriate under the applicable framework and, where comparison is required, whether a transparent adjustment is needed to place periods or businesses on a consistent basis. Any accounting correction must be distinguished from a commercial judgement about what a lender may accept.
3. Revenue Quality: Does the Recorded Revenue Represent Earned and Collectible Activity?
3.1 Revenue must be tested against the underlying customer arrangement
Revenue is often the most sensitive part of a QoE review because EBITDA can be overstated before a cost adjustment is ever considered. The analyst should understand what the company has promised to deliver, when the relevant performance obligation is satisfied, what conditions must be met before the customer is obliged to pay, how variable consideration is estimated and whether the company is acting as principal or agent where that distinction is relevant.
Under IFRS 15, revenue is recognised to depict the transfer of promised goods or services to a customer in an amount that reflects the consideration to which the entity expects to be entitled. The standard requires the entity to identify the contract and performance obligations, determine and allocate the transaction price, and recognise revenue when or as the relevant performance obligation is satisfied. This is a framework-specific reference: a business reporting under another accounting framework must be assessed under that framework. [3]
For a manufacturer, the analyst may test customer purchase orders, master supply agreements, delivery terms, dispatch records, proof of delivery, inspection certificates, customer acceptance clauses, invoice dates, credit notes and receipts after period end. For a contractor, the review may require signed variations, milestone certification, progress reports, engineer approvals and evidence that the contractual right to payment has arisen. An invoice is evidence of a billing event. It is not, on its own, proof that revenue has been earned in the relevant reporting period.
3.2 Worked example: revenue recorded before the performance obligation is satisfied
Assume Aster records a sale of USD 0.80 million on 29 December. The goods are manufactured and invoiced before year-end, but the contract provides that control transfers only when the goods are dispatched from the factory. Dispatch takes place on 5 January. The associated manufacturing cost is USD 0.56 million and has also been charged to cost of goods sold in December.
The December income statement therefore includes:
| Item | USD million |
|---|---|
| Revenue recognised | 0.80 |
| Associated cost of goods sold | (0.56) |
| Gross profit included in reported EBITDA | 0.24 |
If the contract and facts establish that the performance obligation was not satisfied by 31 December, both the premature revenue and the associated cost of sales must be reversed from the historical period. The goods remain in inventory until the relevant revenue-recognition event occurs, subject to the applicable accounting requirements.
| Revenue cut-off correction | USD million |
|---|---|
| Reverse premature revenue | (0.80) |
| Reverse associated cost of goods sold | 0.56 |
| Reduction in EBITDA | (0.24) |
The EBITDA correction is not USD 0.80 million because the associated cost of USD 0.56 million is also reversed. The relevant earnings overstatement is the USD 0.24 million gross profit that should not have been recognised in December. The correction also affects the balance sheet: receivables or contract balances, inventory and potentially customer deposits must be reviewed. The accounting treatment depends on the contractual rights and transfer of control. An acceptance clause that is merely administrative may not have the same effect as a substantive customer acceptance condition. The analyst must read the contract rather than apply a mechanical year-end rule.
3.3 Worked example: rebates, discounts and variable consideration
Aster’s customer terms include an annual volume rebate. During the financial year, a major customer purchases USD 12.0 million of components. The agreement provides for a rebate of 1.5% once the annual volume threshold is achieved. Management has recorded the full sales amount and has not accrued the rebate, although the threshold has been met.
The required calculation is:
Rebate = Eligible sales × Rebate percentage
USD 12.00m × 1.5% = USD 0.18m
If the rebate has not already been recorded through a reduction in revenue or an appropriate accrual, revenue and EBITDA are overstated by USD 0.18 million, subject to the precise accounting and contract terms. The analyst should also test retrospective discounts, price protection, returns, warranty credits, service-level penalties, volume incentives, sales commissions and credit notes issued after year-end. Under IFRS 15, discounts, rebates, refunds, credits and other variable amounts form part of the transaction-price analysis and are subject to the standard’s requirements for estimating and constraining variable consideration. [3]
The commercial implication is important. A company may report revenue growth while the amount it is ultimately entitled to retain is lower than the invoice total. A lender will be interested in both the accounting adjustment and the resulting receivable quality. A buyer will also consider whether the rebate structure is recurring and whether the same commercial terms apply to future periods.
3.4 Customer concentration, churn and the durability of the order book
Historical revenue should be analysed by customer, product, geography, contract and sales channel. A company with USD 60 million of revenue from 200 unrelated customers is not necessarily lower risk than a business with USD 60 million from a small number of investment-grade counterparties. The quality of each relationship depends on contract duration, termination rights, pricing, customer credit, renewal history, operational dependency and the extent to which the supplier can replace the revenue.
A customer roll-forward is often more informative than a single customer-concentration percentage. It should distinguish revenue from retained customers, new customers, lost customers and customers whose purchasing levels have increased or decreased. A new customer added late in the financial year may contribute little to historical earnings but may have a material annualised run-rate effect if the contract has commenced and the business has the capacity to deliver. Conversely, a major customer that has issued a termination notice or declined renewal may make the latest historical EBITDA a poor representation of the business at the transaction date.
Worked example: the loss of a major customer
Assume a customer accounting for USD 6.0 million of Aster’s annual revenue has decided not to renew its supply arrangement. The contract expires after the historical reporting period. Aster’s contribution margin on the customer is 32%, meaning that after the directly variable costs of fulfilling the customer’s orders, USD 0.32 remains from each dollar of revenue to contribute towards fixed operating costs and profit.
| Customer-loss analysis | USD million |
|---|---|
| Annual revenue at risk | 6.00 |
| Less: variable costs at 68% | (4.08) |
| Contribution lost | 1.92 |
| Less: directly avoidable dedicated costs after termination | (0.45) |
| Indicative EBITDA reduction | (1.47) |
The USD 0.45 million represents dedicated costs that Aster can demonstrably eliminate, such as a customer-specific shift or account-support arrangement. It does not include general factory overhead or other costs that will continue after the customer leaves. The calculation therefore estimates a USD 1.47 million reduction in run-rate EBITDA, assuming no replacement customer and no other operational change.
This is not an adjustment to the historical accounts if the customer was still active throughout the historical period and the sale was correctly recognised. It is a pro forma run-rate adjustment reflecting a known change in the business at the date of analysis. The distinction matters because historical QoE and current run-rate analysis answer different questions. A forecast may show that Aster expects to replace the customer, but until there is credible evidence of replacement business, the lost contract should not be neutralised by pipeline revenue.
3.5 Backlog, purchase orders and pipeline are not interchangeable
An order book should be classified by the degree of contractual commitment and delivery certainty. A signed multi-year supply agreement with minimum-volume commitments is different from a framework agreement with no guaranteed orders. A purchase order can be binding, conditional or cancellable depending on the governing contract. A sales forecast or letter of intent may indicate commercial opportunity but may not give the company an enforceable right to consideration.
The analysis should record, at a minimum, the counterparty, contract value, committed minimum volume, delivery schedule, pricing, termination rights, acceptance conditions, credit status, required capital expenditure and expected cash collection. A headline order-book number that includes non-binding pipeline, options or cancellable orders should not be presented as contracted backlog without qualification.
4. Cost Quality: Which Expenses Belong in the Continuing Business?
Revenue quality establishes whether the top line is reliable. Cost quality determines whether the expenses necessary to produce that revenue have been recorded in the right period and at a realistic level. An adjustment is defensible only when the analyst can explain why the recorded cost is not representative of the ongoing business or why the historical accounts have failed to recognise a cost that belongs in the period.
4.1 Owner remuneration and discretionary expenditure
Privately held businesses may contain personal, family or shareholder-related expenditure. Some of it may be genuinely discretionary and removable following a transaction. Other expenditure may be embedded in the business because an owner performs a necessary management, sales, technical or operational function. The analysis must separate the owner as shareholder from the owner as an employee or executive.
Worked example: replacement-cost analysis
Aster’s founder receives annual salary, bonus and benefits of USD 0.60 million. Management proposes adding back the whole amount because the founder expects to reduce his involvement after the transaction. The business, however, will still require a chief executive with responsibility for customer relationships, supplier negotiations and plant oversight. An independent market assessment indicates that the replacement executive package would cost USD 0.35 million, including benefits and employer payroll costs.
| Owner remuneration analysis | USD million |
|---|---|
| Existing founder remuneration included in reported expenses | 0.60 |
| Less: market cost of replacement executive | (0.35) |
| Potential normalisation adjustment | 0.25 |
The appropriate adjustment is USD 0.25 million, not USD 0.60 million. The business continues to require the role and therefore must continue to bear a cost for it. The adjustment removes only the excess of the historical remuneration over the cost required to maintain the operating model.
The same approach applies to family members on payroll, company vehicles, travel, premises, subscriptions and other discretionary expenditure. A payment should not be removed simply because it benefits a shareholder. The company must demonstrate that the expense is not required for the continuing business, that the relevant person or service will no longer be required, and that no replacement expenditure will arise. Where a family member performs a genuine operating function, the analysis should use a supportable replacement cost rather than assume the entire package can be eliminated.
4.2 Unusual and non-recurring costs: the burden of proof
A genuine one-off cost may be appropriate for adjustment where it relates to a discrete event that is not representative of the company’s continuing operations. Examples can include a specific legal settlement relating to a concluded dispute, an exceptional casualty clean-up, or professional costs incurred on a completed transaction that is not part of the company’s ordinary acquisition programme.
The label is not enough. The analyst should establish the nature of the event, the amount recorded, the period in which it was recognised, whether the cost was actually incurred, whether it has been paid or remains payable, whether the event is concluded, whether similar costs arose in other periods and whether the business will incur replacement expenditure. A settlement may be unusual; the legal costs of maintaining ordinary customer, employment and regulatory relationships are not automatically unusual. A company that undertakes acquisitions every year should not assume that every acquisition fee is economically non-recurring merely because each transaction is separate.
Worked example: a discrete legal settlement
Assume Aster recorded USD 0.30 million of legal settlement expense in the historical year following the conclusion of a specific contractual dispute. The settlement agreement, board approval, legal invoices and payment records are available. The dispute is concluded, no related claim remains outstanding, and the cost does not relate to ordinary contract administration or a recurring category of litigation.
If the evidence supports those facts, the USD 0.30 million may be considered as an adjustment to historical EBITDA. The analyst should nevertheless review any continuing legal costs, claims, indemnities or obligations arising from the matter. If the company continues to incur equivalent settlement costs each year, the claim that the expense is non-recurring becomes substantially weaker. The adjustment is not a reward for describing a cost as exceptional; it is a correction for a historical event that is demonstrably not part of the continuing earnings base.
The SEC’s published non-GAAP interpretations are a useful warning against excluding ordinary operating costs simply because they occur irregularly. Under the relevant US disclosure rules, an expense that occurs repeatedly or occasionally, including at irregular intervals, may still be recurring. This legal guidance applies to the relevant SEC reporting context, but it reinforces a broader underwriting principle: recurrence must be assessed by economic substance and the company’s operating history, not merely by the date or label attached to an invoice. [2]
4.3 Repeated “one-off” costs can be part of the business model
A company may describe restructuring, technology implementation, recruitment, compliance, maintenance or professional-services costs as exceptional. If similar costs arise year after year, the analyst should consider whether they form part of the ordinary cost of maintaining or improving the business. An individual project may have a defined start and end date, but the business may have a continuing requirement to undertake projects of that type.
For example, Aster has expensed USD 0.50 million in the year for ERP upgrades and systems support. Management proposes adding the full amount back as a transformation expense. The general ledger and supplier invoices show that the company has incurred between USD 0.40 million and USD 0.55 million on systems upgrades, support and related services in each of the preceding three years. The systems are integral to manufacturing scheduling, inventory control and customer delivery.
On these facts, a full USD 0.50 million add-back is not justified merely because the current workstream has been labelled a transformation project. The company appears to incur a continuing cost to maintain and improve its systems. A discrete implementation project may warrant separate analysis if it is genuinely completed and does not recur, but recurring support, upgrades and ordinary maintenance should remain in the earnings base. If management believes the programme has permanently changed the cost structure, it should show the actual post-implementation cost, the contracts terminated, new costs incurred and evidence that the lower cost base is sustainable.
4.4 Related-party transactions must be brought to a supportable commercial basis
Related-party arrangements can affect earnings in either direction. A business may pay above-market rent to a property owned by a shareholder, employ a family member at above-market remuneration, receive services from a connected company at inflated prices, or occupy premises owned by its founder at below-market rent. The QoE review should identify the relationship, understand the contractual arrangement and assess what the company would reasonably incur on arm’s-length terms after the transaction.
IAS 24, where applicable, requires disclosure of related-party relationships and transactions so that users can understand how they may have affected the entity’s financial position and profit or loss. Those disclosures are a starting point for diligence, not proof that the pricing is commercial. The analyst should review the underlying agreement, invoices, payment record, scope of services and market evidence. [4]
Worked example: above-market related-party rent
Aster pays USD 0.75 million annually for factory and administrative premises leased from an entity controlled by the founder. An independent property assessment indicates that comparable premises with similar area, location and condition would cost approximately USD 0.60 million annually. Assume the USD 0.75 million rent is included as an operating expense in the EBITDA figure presented for this example.
Potential adjustment = Recorded rent - Market replacement rent
USD 0.75m - USD 0.60m = USD 0.15m
If the company can continue to occupy suitable premises at the market rent and no additional transaction or relocation cost is required, a USD 0.15 million upward adjustment may be supportable. If the lease is not transferable, if the property is essential and the market evidence is weak, or if relocation would require additional capex, the conclusion may differ.
The direction can also be negative. If Aster pays USD 0.45 million to a related party for premises that would cost USD 0.60 million in the market, the continuing business may face an additional USD 0.15 million annual occupancy cost. Normalised EBITDA would then reduce by USD 0.15 million.
Lease-accounting qualification: the example above assumes rent is recorded as an operating expense within EBITDA. Under IFRS 16, a lessee generally recognises a right-of-use asset and lease liability for leases within the standard’s scope, with depreciation and interest presented separately. Consequently, the lease expense may not reduce EBITDA in the same way as it would under a rent-expense presentation. The analyst must identify the accounting basis, maintain comparability and ensure that lease liabilities are treated consistently in leverage and enterprise-value analysis. A rent adjustment must not be inserted mechanically into an EBITDA measure that has already been calculated on an IFRS 16 basis. [8]
4.5 Accruals, provisions and costs that have not been fully recognised
An apparently strong EBITDA result can arise because the company has not recorded all costs attributable to the period. This can happen when supplier invoices arrive after year-end, customer claims remain unresolved, employee bonuses are not accrued, warranty costs are understated or a contract has become loss-making. The QoE review should test completeness of liabilities as well as the validity of management’s proposed add-backs.
Worked example: warranty provision shortfall
Aster has a two-year product warranty. Its accounts include a warranty expense or provision of USD 0.45 million for the relevant period. A review of product cohorts, claims history, field-failure rates and claims received after year-end indicates that the expected obligation attributable to products already sold is USD 0.65 million. Assuming the underlying accounting assessment supports that amount and it has not been recognised elsewhere, the historical cost base is understated by USD 0.20 million.
Additional warranty accrual = Expected obligation - Recorded provision
USD 0.65m - USD 0.45m = USD 0.20m
The QoE adjustment is therefore a USD 0.20 million reduction in EBITDA. The fact that the cash settlement may occur in a later period does not make the cost irrelevant to the earnings generated by the sales that created the warranty obligation. Under IAS 37, where applicable, provisions are recognised for obligations of uncertain timing or amount when the relevant recognition criteria are met; warranty obligations are an example of a matter that may give rise to a provision. [5]
A similar approach applies to annual bonuses, sales commissions, customer rebates, accrued freight, employee leave, maintenance obligations and supplier claims. The analyst must determine which period the expense belongs to, whether the obligation exists at the reporting date, what evidence supports the estimate and whether the amount has already been recognised in EBITDA or another balance-sheet account.
4.6 Inventory valuation and the cost of obsolete stock
Inventory is a frequent source of earnings-quality adjustments in manufacturing, distribution, textiles, food processing and other stock-intensive businesses. The book value of inventory is not automatically its recoverable economic value. Stock may be obsolete, damaged, slow-moving, held for a discontinued product, subject to a price decline or incapable of being sold without significant rework.
Under IAS 2, where applicable, inventory is measured at the lower of cost and net realisable value. Net realisable value is the estimated selling price in the ordinary course of business less estimated costs of completion and costs necessary to make the sale. A write-down is recognised as an expense in the period in which the loss occurs. [6]
Worked example: inventory requiring a write-down
Aster holds a batch of discontinued components with a recorded cost of USD 0.30 million. The product can now be sold only as surplus stock for an estimated USD 0.14 million. A further USD 0.04 million will be required for testing, repacking and disposal-related selling costs. The estimated net realisable value is therefore:
Net realisable value = Expected selling price - Costs to complete and sell
USD 0.14m - USD 0.04m = USD 0.10m
The required write-down is:
Inventory write-down = Carrying cost - Net realisable value
USD 0.30m - USD 0.10m = USD 0.20m
If that write-down has not been recorded, historical EBITDA is overstated by USD 0.20 million, assuming the relevant inventory expense flows through the income statement. The analyst should verify the item-level inventory listing, last movement date, customer demand, subsequent sales, physical condition, alternative uses and disposal costs. A broad percentage reserve applied to total stock may be inadequate where the risk is concentrated in specific product lines or batches.
An inventory write-down should not be added back merely because management calls it exceptional. A discontinued product may be an unusual event, but slow-moving or obsolete stock may also reflect ordinary forecasting, procurement and product-life-cycle risk. The analyst must understand why the loss arose and whether comparable losses have occurred in other periods.
4.7 Capitalised operating expenditure can inflate EBITDA
The distinction between operating expenditure and capital expenditure matters because routine operating costs are generally deducted in arriving at EBITDA, while qualifying capital expenditure is recorded on the balance sheet and depreciated over time. If a company capitalises costs that should have been expensed, reported EBITDA may be overstated in the period in which the expenditure is incurred.
Worked example: routine maintenance recorded as capital expenditure
Aster spends USD 0.25 million on routine servicing of production equipment. The work consists of labour, consumables and small replacement parts required to keep the existing machine in its current operating condition. Management has capitalised the full amount as plant and machinery, even though the work does not create a separately identifiable enhancement or replacement component that qualifies for capitalisation under the applicable accounting policy.
If the expenditure is properly classified as routine servicing and should have been recognised in profit or loss, the QoE review records an adjustment of USD 0.25 million against EBITDA. The corresponding asset balance and any depreciation already recorded must also be examined to avoid a second adjustment. IAS 16, where applicable, distinguishes day-to-day servicing costs, which are recognised in profit or loss as incurred, from qualifying costs that may be recognised in the carrying amount of property, plant and equipment. [7]
This adjustment is particularly important where management presents low maintenance expenditure as evidence of strong cash conversion. A company cannot improve EBITDA merely by moving routine operating expenditure to the fixed-asset register. The analyst should inspect the capex ledger, invoices, work orders, technical descriptions, fixed-asset additions, useful lives and subsequent maintenance requirements.
4.8 Acquisitions, disposals and synergy claims
An acquisition can increase reported EBITDA only from the date and in the manner required by the applicable accounting framework. A buyer may nevertheless need a pro forma view that reflects the acquired business as though it had been owned for a full period. That adjustment should be shown separately from the target’s historical QoE adjustments and should be supported by the acquired company’s financial records, accounting-policy alignment, stand-alone cost base and integration requirements.
Synergies require a higher degree of discipline. A proposed saving should be classified according to whether it is identified, approved, implemented, realised, recurring and net of the cost required to achieve it. Removing a duplicated head-office role after an acquisition may be a credible run-rate adjustment once the role has actually been eliminated and the remaining organisation can perform the work. A forecast to renegotiate supplier prices, consolidate plants or introduce automation is not an earnings adjustment merely because management has included it in a business plan.
Assume Aster has completed a small acquisition after the historical year. The acquired company generated USD 1.20 million of EBITDA in the last full year, but the combination requires USD 0.25 million of additional compliance, finance and operational support costs. A possible pro forma contribution is not USD 1.20 million automatically. The analyst must test the acquired earnings, align accounting policies, assess whether the customer and employee base will remain, and deduct the cost of operating the combined business. The resulting contribution may be USD 0.95 million before any separately evidenced synergy, but only if the acquired EBITDA and additional cost assumptions are substantiated.
The same principle applies to disposals. Where a business or product line has been sold or is to be removed, its contribution may need to be excluded from the transaction-date run rate. The analyst should identify shared overhead that will remain, separation costs, transitional service arrangements and any stranded costs that the continuing business will have to absorb.
5. The Adjustment Test: What Makes an Add-Back Defensible?
An adjustment should be assessed on its merits rather than by the category under which management places it. The analyst should be able to answer a consistent set of questions before including it in diligence-adjusted EBITDA.
| Test | Question for the analyst | Evidence normally expected |
|---|---|---|
| Traceability | Can the adjustment be tied to the accounting records and the relevant reporting period? | Trial balance, general ledger, journal entry, invoice, payroll record or contract. |
| Economic substance | What actually happened, and why does the item distort the continuing earnings base? | Explanation supported by the underlying event, contract, correspondence or operating record. |
| Non-recurrence | Is the cost or gain genuinely non-recurring in the context of this business, or does it arise periodically? | Multi-year history, prior-period ledger analysis and evidence of similar events. |
| Avoidability | Will the cost cease after the transaction or change in operating model? | Termination notices, completed actions, revised organisation chart, supplier cancellation or evidence of cessation. |
| Replacement cost | Will the business need to incur another cost to perform the same function? | Market salary data, replacement contract, independent valuation or supplier quote. |
| Measurement | Is the amount correct, net of recoveries, insurance, replacement expenditure and related items? | Invoices, settlement statements, insurance receipts and calculation schedules. |
| Period consistency | Has the adjustment been treated consistently across historical periods? | Comparable prior-year calculations and a documented methodology. |
| No duplication | Has the same item already been adjusted in another line or included in a pro forma schedule? | Adjustment cross-reference, balance-sheet reconciliation and model checks. |
| Continuing operations | Does the adjustment reflect the business that will actually exist after the transaction? | Operating plan, customer and employee status, contracts and post-period evidence. |
A useful way to manage the process is to assign each proposed adjustment a status. The following is an internal analytical classification, not a standard prescribed by an accounting body or lender.
| Status | Meaning | Treatment in the analysis |
|---|---|---|
| Supported historical adjustment | The event is evidenced, correctly measured and relevant to the historical period. | May be included in diligence-adjusted historical EBITDA, subject to final review. |
| Conditional or partially supported | The rationale may be valid, but the amount, timing, replacement cost or recurrence remains uncertain. | Show separately with the unresolved condition; do not present as fully accepted. |
| Pro forma run-rate item | The event occurred after the historical period or reflects a change to the operating perimeter. | Present separately from historical QoE and explain the effective date and evidence. |
| Forecast or speculative item | The adjustment depends on a future event, management initiative, unsigned contract or unimplemented plan. | Exclude from historical and current run-rate EBITDA; retain only in the forecast with explicit assumptions. |
| Rejected adjustment | The cost is recurring, necessary, unsupported, incorrectly measured or duplicative. | Do not add back; explain the reason for rejection. |
The test is not whether an adjustment is favourable to the seller or buyer. It is whether it is analytically supportable. A seller may identify genuine owner-specific costs that should be removed. A buyer may identify revenue cut-off errors, omitted liabilities or recurring costs that reduce earnings. Both sides should want a reconciliation that can be reconstructed from the books.
6. Aster Precision Components: The Full EBITDA Reconciliation
The preceding examples can now be brought together into one transaction-style earnings bridge. Aster has reported EBITDA of USD 8.00 million. Management presents a higher number after applying its own add-backs. The diligence review tests both upward and downward adjustments and then separately considers the change in the customer base after the historical reporting period.
6.1 Management’s proposed adjusted EBITDA
Management’s schedule contains the following adjustments:
| Management adjustment schedule | USD million | Management rationale |
|---|---|---|
| Reported EBITDA | 8.00 | Historical reported result. |
| Add: full founder remuneration | 0.60 | Founder expects to reduce involvement. |
| Add: concluded legal settlement | 0.30 | Discrete legal matter. |
| Add: ERP and systems programme | 0.50 | Described as a transformation expense. |
| Add: planned staff savings | 0.45 | Expected savings from a proposed organisation change. |
| Management-adjusted EBITDA | 9.85 | Management’s proposed earnings figure. |
The USD 9.85 million figure is not automatically invalid because management has prepared it. It is a proposal that requires testing. The full founder remuneration add-back ignores the replacement cost of the continuing management role. The ERP programme has been incurred in similar amounts in each of the preceding three years and appears to be a continuing cost of maintaining the systems required to operate the business. The planned staff savings have not yet been implemented. Management’s schedule also does not reflect the revenue and cost corrections identified in the QoE review.
6.2 Diligence-adjusted historical EBITDA
| Reconciliation item | Adjustment | Explanation |
|---|---|---|
| Reported EBITDA | 8.00 | Starting point reconciled to the historical accounts. |
| Excess founder remuneration | +0.25 | USD 0.60m existing package less USD 0.35m replacement cost. |
| Concluded legal settlement | +0.30 | Discrete matter supported by settlement and payment records. |
| Above-market related-party rent | +0.15 | USD 0.75m recorded rent less USD 0.60m market rent, assuming rent is expensed in EBITDA. |
| Premature revenue cut-off | (0.24) | USD 0.80m premature sale less USD 0.56m associated cost of sales. |
| Unrecorded customer rebate | (0.18) | 1.5% rebate on USD 12.00m eligible customer purchases. |
| Warranty provision shortfall | (0.20) | Expected obligation of USD 0.65m less recorded USD 0.45m. |
| Inventory valuation shortfall | (0.20) | USD 0.30m carrying cost less USD 0.10m net realisable value. |
| Routine maintenance capitalised | (0.25) | Expenditure should have been charged to operating expenses. |
| Diligence-adjusted historical EBITDA | 7.63 | Historical earnings after the adjustments supported by the review. |
The calculation is:
USD 8.00m + 0.25m + 0.30m + 0.15m - 0.24m - 0.18m - 0.20m - 0.20m - 0.25m = USD 7.63m
There are three important observations. First, the positive adjustments total USD 0.70 million, but the negative corrections total USD 1.07 million. A QoE review that had examined only the add-backs would have missed the more significant issue: the historical cost and revenue base was not complete. Second, the result is not an arbitrary haircut. Each item is connected to a specific accounting entry, contract, provision, market reference or operating fact. Third, the conclusion is historical. It does not yet incorporate the customer non-renewal or the subsequent cost reduction.
6.3 Pro forma run-rate EBITDA at the transaction date
After the historical period, Aster implements a facility and back-office consolidation that produces a verified recurring annual saving of USD 0.20 million. The relevant roles have been removed, the revised organisation is operational, no equivalent replacement costs have arisen and the saving is not included in the historical EBITDA bridge. This item may be considered separately as a pro forma run-rate adjustment.
Aster also receives formal notice that its customer representing USD 6.00 million of annual revenue will not renew its supply arrangement. As demonstrated earlier, the lost contribution after variable costs is USD 1.92 million. Dedicated costs of USD 0.45 million can be eliminated, leaving an estimated EBITDA reduction of USD 1.47 million.
| Pro forma bridge | USD million |
|---|---|
| Diligence-adjusted historical EBITDA | 7.63 |
| Add: implemented and evidenced annual cost saving | +0.20 |
| Less: lost customer contribution, net of avoidable costs | (1.47) |
| Illustrative pro forma run-rate EBITDA | 6.36 |
This is the more relevant figure for an investment or financing decision made after the customer non-renewal has become effective and the cost action has been implemented, subject to confirmation of the timing and facts. It does not mean that USD 6.36 million is automatically the EBITDA a lender will use. A lender may require further adjustments, apply a downside case or use a contractual covenant definition. The figure is simply the current pro forma earnings conclusion supported by the facts in this illustration.
6.4 What happened to the margin?
The revenue adjustments also change the revenue denominator. The premature sale of USD 0.80 million and the unrecorded rebate of USD 0.18 million reduce historical revenue from USD 60.00 million to USD 59.02 million. Diligence-adjusted historical EBITDA of USD 7.63 million therefore represents a margin of approximately 12.9% on adjusted revenue.
After the loss of the USD 6.00 million customer, illustrative pro forma revenue is USD 53.02 million. Pro forma EBITDA of USD 6.36 million represents a margin of approximately 12.0%. The margin calculation is a sense check, not a separate valuation conclusion. It helps the analyst assess whether the remaining earnings base is consistent with the company’s product mix, factory utilisation, overhead structure and customer economics.
7. Why the Adjustment Changes the Transaction
7.1 Enterprise value sensitivity
In many private-company transactions, enterprise value is discussed by reference to an EBITDA multiple. The multiple is not a statutory formula; it is a valuation convention used alongside an assessment of sector, scale, growth, recurring revenue, margins, capital requirements, customer concentration, management quality and transaction conditions.
Assume, only to isolate the effect of the earnings denominator, that an illustrative valuation multiple of 6.0x is applied to each EBITDA measure.
| Earnings measure | EBITDA (USD m) | Assumed multiple | Indicative enterprise value (USD m) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Management-adjusted EBITDA | 9.85 | 6.0x | 59.10 |
| Diligence-adjusted historical EBITDA | 7.63 | 6.0x | 45.78 |
| Pro forma run-rate EBITDA | 6.36 | 6.0x | 38.16 |
The difference between management’s USD 9.85 million and the pro forma USD 6.36 million is USD 3.49 million of EBITDA. At 6.0x, the mechanical enterprise-value difference is USD 20.94 million.
Enterprise value difference = EBITDA difference × Assumed valuation multiple
USD 3.49m × 6.0 = USD 20.94m
This does not mean that a buyer should automatically pay USD 38.16 million, or that the multiple should remain unchanged. A buyer may apply a lower multiple if the customer loss increases concentration or reduces growth prospects. Alternatively, the buyer may conclude that the lost customer can be replaced with credible contracted demand and that the risk is temporary. The point is that earnings quality can affect both parts of the valuation equation: the earnings denominator and the multiple applied to it.
7.2 Mechanical leverage sensitivity
The same denominator affects a leverage calculation. Assume, strictly for illustration, that a lender tests gross funded debt at 4.0x EBITDA. This is an assumed ratio for demonstrating the arithmetic, not a statement of market terms or a conclusion that the business qualifies for 4.0x leverage.
| Earnings measure | EBITDA (USD m) | Assumed gross leverage | Mechanical debt amount (USD m) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Management-adjusted EBITDA | 9.85 | 4.0x | 39.40 |
| Diligence-adjusted historical EBITDA | 7.63 | 4.0x | 30.52 |
| Pro forma run-rate EBITDA | 6.36 | 4.0x | 25.44 |
The difference between management’s figure and the pro forma run rate produces USD 13.96 million of mechanical debt-sizing difference at the assumed leverage ratio:
USD 3.49m EBITDA difference × 4.0 = USD 13.96m
A credit committee would not approve a facility solely because the borrower passes a leverage calculation. It would also examine interest coverage, scheduled amortisation, cash conversion, maintenance capex, working capital, existing debt, collateral, covenant headroom, currency exposure, tenor, maturity and downside performance. The lender may also apply a leverage ratio to a different EBITDA definition from the independent QoE figure, particularly where the credit agreement expressly permits or caps certain pro forma adjustments.
7.3 Enterprise value is not equity value
A common source of misunderstanding in a transaction is the assumption that the enterprise value derived from EBITDA is the amount shareholders will receive. In a conventional cash-free, debt-free acquisition structure, the equity value is generally derived by adjusting enterprise value for cash, debt and debt-like items, and the agreed working-capital position. The precise definitions and mechanics are negotiated in the sale and purchase agreement and vary by transaction.
A simplified illustration is:
Equity value = Enterprise value - Net debt - Debt-like items ± Working-capital adjustment
Assume a business is agreed at an enterprise value of USD 45.78 million. If it has USD 8.00 million of funded debt, USD 1.00 million of cash, USD 0.50 million of agreed debt-like items and a USD 0.30 million working-capital shortfall against the agreed target, the illustrative equity value would be:
| Enterprise-to-equity bridge | USD million |
|---|---|
| Enterprise value | 45.78 |
| Less: funded debt | (8.00) |
| Add: cash | +1.00 |
| Less: agreed debt-like items | (0.50) |
| Less: working-capital shortfall | (0.30) |
| Illustrative equity value | 37.98 |
This calculation is only illustrative. The treatment of leases, overdue creditors, tax liabilities, transaction expenses, customer deposits, unpaid bonuses, deferred consideration and other items depends on the SPA definitions and the facts. Some items may be included in net debt, others in working capital, and some may be treated separately. The same economic loss should not be deducted twice.
7.4 Do not confuse QoE adjustments with net debt and working-capital adjustments
QoE, net debt and working-capital analysis are related but distinct workstreams. A missing expense may reduce EBITDA because it belongs in the historical income statement. The related unpaid liability may also be relevant to the closing balance sheet. Whether it affects the purchase-price bridge depends on how the SPA defines working capital and debt-like items. A credit note may reduce revenue and EBITDA while also reducing receivables. An inventory write-down may reduce EBITDA while the resulting lower inventory balance affects closing working capital. The transaction analysis must track both effects and avoid double counting.
| Item identified in diligence | Potential earnings treatment | Potential balance-sheet or purchase-price treatment |
|---|---|---|
| Customer rebate not accrued | Reduce historical revenue and EBITDA if attributable to the period. | Review the corresponding receivable, credit note or accrual and the SPA’s working-capital definition. |
| Warranty provision shortfall | Reduce EBITDA where the expected cost belongs to the historical period. | Review the provision or liability and whether it is treated as working capital or a separate debt-like item. |
| Obsolete inventory | Reduce EBITDA for an unrecorded write-down where required. | Ensure closing inventory is valued consistently and the same write-down is not deducted again. |
| Overdue supplier invoice for ordinary operating costs | Reduce EBITDA if the expense belongs to the historical period and was omitted. | Review whether the unpaid amount is ordinary working capital or a debt-like item under the agreed definition. |
| Capitalised routine maintenance | Reduce EBITDA if the cost should have been expensed. | Review fixed assets and depreciation so that the correction is not duplicated in the closing balance sheet. |
PwC’s description of financial due diligence separately identifies quality of earnings, net working capital, diligence analytics and contractual closing mechanisms. That separation is commercially important: the earnings analysis informs valuation and financing, while the working-capital and net-debt work informs the closing economics and purchase-price adjustment mechanics. [9]
8. Lease Accounting and Comparability: A Common EBITDA Trap
Lease accounting can materially change EBITDA comparability between businesses and across reporting periods. Under IFRS 16, a lessee generally recognises a right-of-use asset and a lease liability for leases within the standard’s scope, subject to specified exemptions. The income statement presentation generally separates right-of-use asset depreciation and lease-liability interest rather than recognising the full lease payment as a single operating rental expense. This can increase reported EBITDA compared with an earlier rent-expense presentation, even though the business continues to make the contractual lease payments. [8]
The analyst should therefore establish whether the EBITDA measure is presented before or after the effects of IFRS 16 and whether lease liabilities are included in gross debt or net debt for the leverage calculation. A buyer may use an EBITDA figure that includes the IFRS 16 uplift while also recognising lease liabilities in enterprise-to-equity or leverage analysis. Alternatively, a transaction model may use a lease-adjusted EBITDA and debt presentation for comparability. The key is consistency between the numerator, denominator, debt measure and valuation convention.
A simplified example demonstrates the issue. Assume two otherwise identical businesses each pay annual cash rent of USD 1.00 million. Under a rent-expense presentation, the rent reduces EBITDA by USD 1.00 million. Under an IFRS 16 presentation, the operating statement may instead show depreciation and interest relating to the lease, with the full rent payment reflected through lease-liability accounting and cash flow. EBITDA may therefore be higher, even though the cash lease payment remains economically real.
A lender assessing leverage should not conclude that the IFRS 16 business has more cash available simply because its EBITDA is higher. It must identify lease payments, lease liabilities, cash-flow treatment and the contractual EBITDA definition. A loan agreement may expressly state whether lease liabilities are included in indebtedness, whether lease expenses are added back or deducted, and how lease obligations are treated for covenant purposes. No one treatment should be assumed without reading the documents.
9. From Reported EBITDA to the Figure Used by a Lender or Investor
9.1 There may be more than one accepted EBITDA figure
A QoE provider may conclude that historical sustainable EBITDA is USD 7.63 million. An investor may use USD 7.63 million as its initial valuation reference but apply a separate downside case. A senior lender may use a more conservative underwritten EBITDA figure. A credit agreement may define covenant EBITDA to include specific acquisition, restructuring or run-rate adjustments, subject to documentary requirements and negotiated caps. A financial sponsor may model a separate case that assumes completed operational improvements.
These measures are not automatically inconsistent. They serve different purposes. What matters is that they are clearly labelled and that each can be reconciled to its underlying assumptions.
| Measure | Typical purpose | Core discipline |
|---|---|---|
| Reported EBITDA | Historical reference point | Reconcile to accounting records and stated calculation. |
| Diligence-adjusted historical EBITDA | Quality-of-earnings conclusion | Include only adjustments supported by evidence and attributable to the historical period. |
| Pro forma run-rate EBITDA | Reflect a changed operating perimeter or implemented actions | Separate post-period events and quantify the effective date, ongoing cost and evidence. |
| Forecast EBITDA | Business plan and valuation scenario | State assumptions, execution requirements, timing and sensitivities. |
| Underwritten EBITDA | Investor or lender’s internal assessment | Apply the institution’s risk approach, mandate and downside requirements. |
| Covenant EBITDA | Contractual financial covenant calculation | Follow the negotiated definition, caps, baskets, testing dates and supporting requirements in the finance documents. |
A promoter should not assume that because an adjustment appears in a seller-side QoE schedule, it will also be permitted under a lender’s covenant definition. Nor should a lender assume that the EBITDA definition agreed in a finance document is an independent conclusion about the company’s sustainable earnings. A contractual formula is an allocation of rights and risks between the parties; it is not an accounting opinion.
9.2 How different capital providers use earnings quality
A senior secured lender is principally concerned with repayment from cash generated by the borrower, together with the value and enforceability of its collateral package. It will use EBITDA as one input into leverage and coverage analysis, but will also examine the stability of revenue, cash conversion, capex, working-capital seasonality, interest costs, amortisation and downside performance. The lender may reject adjustments that are not fully evidenced or that depend on management actions which have not been completed.
A unitranche or mezzanine provider may underwrite a higher-risk position in the capital structure and may be prepared to consider a different balance of cash-pay and payment-in-kind interest, tenor, amortisation and return. That does not make an overstated earnings figure more reliable. Higher leverage can amplify the consequence of a revenue shortfall or an unsupported add-back, while a bullet maturity can defer repayment pressure rather than remove it.
A private equity investor or strategic buyer will use sustainable EBITDA to inform enterprise valuation, entry leverage, return analysis and the resources available to implement its business plan. The investor may place value on operational improvements that it expects to deliver, but those improvements should be modelled as a value-creation plan with cost, timing and execution risk. They should not be passed off as earnings that the target already generates.
For all three groups, weaknesses in financial reporting can affect process and terms. Incomplete monthly accounts, weak inventory controls, unexplained journal entries, repeated restatements, material related-party balances and gaps between audited accounts and tax or management records can lead to further diligence, additional conditions, a smaller facility, a different capital instrument, stronger covenant protections or a decision not to proceed.
10. Preparing for an Institutional QoE Review
A company should prepare its earnings evidence before approaching institutional capital. The objective is not to manufacture a higher EBITDA figure. It is to make the reported performance traceable, identify adjustments in advance and ensure that management can explain the commercial facts behind the numbers.
| Information set | What the review is trying to establish | Typical supporting documents |
|---|---|---|
| Historical financial statements | Accounting baseline, audit findings and consistency between periods. | Audited financial statements, audit adjustments, accounting policies and notes. |
| Monthly management accounts | Trading trends, seasonality, margin movements and LTM performance. | Monthly P&L, balance sheet, cash-flow reports and management commentary. |
| Trial balance and general ledger | Traceability of reported figures and adjustment entries. | Trial balances, ledger extracts, journal listings and chart of accounts. |
| Revenue and customer records | Whether sales are earned, correctly timed, collectible and diversified. | Customer contracts, purchase orders, invoices, dispatch records, acceptance certificates, credit notes and subsequent receipts. |
| Customer analysis | Customer concentration, churn, renewal exposure and order-book quality. | Revenue by customer, top-customer schedules, contract expiry dates, renewal correspondence and backlog reports. |
| Payroll and related-party records | Owner compensation, family employment and non-market arrangements. | Payroll register, executive service agreements, bonus schedules, related-party register and board approvals. |
| Supplier and operating-cost records | Completeness, recurrence and classification of operating costs. | Supplier ledger, invoices, maintenance records, service agreements and post-year-end payments. |
| Inventory | Obsolescence, reserves, cost accuracy and existence. | Stock listing, ageing, physical counts, subsequent sales, scrap reports and net-realisable-value analysis. |
| Warranty and other provisions | Completeness and measurement of obligations attributable to historical sales. | Claims history, warranty cohorts, legal correspondence, provision workings and subsequent settlements. |
| Fixed assets and capex | Correct classification of expenditure and sustainable maintenance needs. | Fixed-asset register, capex ledger, purchase invoices, work orders and maintenance plans. |
| Debt and lease schedules | Financing costs, debt-like items, lease obligations and covenant calculations. | Facility agreements, repayment schedules, security register, lease schedule and covenant certificates. |
| Post-period developments | Changes between the historical reporting date and the transaction date. | Subsequent management accounts, customer notices, contracts signed, staff changes, cost actions and material claims. |
Management should also prepare an adjustment register. Each adjustment should state the amount, period, account code, description, reason proposed, evidence, replacement cost if relevant, recurrence history, whether cash has been paid, whether the action is complete, and whether the item affects the balance sheet as well as EBITDA. The register should show rejected and negative adjustments, not only positive add-backs.
Where the company has weak records, the immediate priority may be to reconcile the accounts, improve month-end reporting, document related-party arrangements, complete inventory ageing or clarify customer contract terms. Those steps may be more valuable than approaching multiple capital providers with an earnings presentation that is unlikely to survive preliminary diligence.
11. Common Errors That Weaken a Financing or Sale Process
Presenting management-adjusted EBITDA as though it were audited EBITDA. Management adjustments are proposals. They should be separately identified and reconciled rather than embedded in the historical figure.
Adding back the full cost of an owner or executive. The business may still require the function. The adjustment should generally reflect the difference between actual cost and the cost of a suitable replacement, if that difference is evidenced.
Treating all professional fees as exceptional. Legal, accounting, audit, compliance and advisory costs may be ordinary requirements of the business. A discrete transaction or concluded litigation matter may be analysed separately, but the continuing cost of maintaining the company must remain.
Ignoring negative adjustments. A complete review examines revenue cut-off, rebates, claims, inventory, warranty provisions, unrecorded expenses, capitalised operating costs and customer losses. The analysis should not be designed to increase EBITDA.
Treating pipeline as contracted revenue. Unsigned opportunities, non-binding letters of intent and cancellable orders may support a forecast, but they do not necessarily support a historical or current run-rate adjustment.
Annualising a favourable month. A strong production or billing month may reflect seasonality, one-off deliveries or timing rather than a sustainable operating level. The analyst should identify the reason and reconcile to the full period.
Ignoring the balance sheet. Revenue cut-off, inventory valuation, rebates, warranty provisions and capitalisation all have balance-sheet consequences. The income statement adjustment should be reconciled to the relevant asset or liability and the purchase-price mechanics.
Applying an EBITDA multiple without reviewing the quality of earnings. Two businesses with the same reported EBITDA may have materially different valuation characteristics if one has recurring revenue, diversified customers and low maintenance requirements while the other depends on one contract, underfunds maintenance and carries unrecorded liabilities.
Assuming that EBITDA equals debt capacity. EBITDA does not deduct cash taxes, working-capital investment, maintenance capex or debt service. The next analytical step is to establish how much cash the business can generate after meeting those requirements. That is the subject of the following article in this series.
12. The Commercial Implication: Build the Financing Case Around the Earnings the Business Can Prove
The purpose of a QoE review is not to produce a presentation number that looks attractive. It is to establish the financial basis on which a transaction can be evaluated. For a promoter, that means knowing which earnings are genuinely recurring, which adjustments can be substantiated, what adverse items need to be corrected and how much financing the business can responsibly support. For a lender or investor, it means understanding the cash-generating enterprise behind the reported EBITDA and identifying where historical performance may not continue.
A business may have strong underlying prospects but insufficient current debt capacity. It may need a combination of senior debt and equity, a working-capital facility supported by eligible receivables, equipment finance, a staged capex facility or a strategic investor. A business with sound earnings but weak financial reporting may need to improve its information base before institutional engagement. A business whose EBITDA has been inflated by temporary revenue or unrecorded costs may require a reset of the proposed capital requirement. The correct capital solution follows the verified facts; it should not be reverse-engineered from the promoter’s preferred funding amount.
For institutional managers, the same analysis informs transaction structure. A lower verified earnings base may change the level of acquisition leverage, the sponsor equity contribution, the use of preferred or subordinated capital, the collateral package, the covenant design and the conditions that must be satisfied before drawdown. Where the target is part of a cross-border transaction, the entity that earns the cash flow, the entity that borrows, the entity that owns the assets and the entity that grants security must also be mapped before the financing structure can be regarded as executable.
The governing principle is simple: the transaction should be structured around the earnings the business can demonstrate, not the earnings it hopes a capital provider will accept.
13. Taking the Analysis into a Transaction
For a company considering a material financing, acquisition or shareholder transaction, the first useful step is to prepare a concise non-confidential outline of the business and the proposed transaction. It should identify the operating sector and geography, the capital requirement and use of proceeds, historical revenue and EBITDA ranges, existing debt and material security, the principal customer or contract dependencies, and the current stage of the transaction. The outline should distinguish audited results, management-adjusted EBITDA and any independent QoE findings. It should not include confidential customer names, bank statements, employee-level payroll information or unrestricted financial data in an initial approach.
For investment managers, sponsors and professional advisers, the relevant question may arise one level later. A QoE finding may change the acquisition price, borrower entity, financing quantum, equity contribution, covenant package, security structure or execution sequence. Where the issue concerns how those components fit together, the transaction should be described by reference to the assets, vehicles, jurisdictions, financing terms, stage and unresolved constraint. The financial diligence provider, auditor, tax adviser and legal counsel should retain responsibility for their respective professional opinions and formal workstreams.
Bayswater Transflow works on transaction architecture for private-market managers and complex cross-border transactions. It does not act as the lender, investment manager, auditor or provider of an audit opinion. Where a financial finding creates a structural question about the vehicle, financing, security, economics or sequence of a transaction, a professional or institutional reader may request an introductory discussion through the Bayswater contact page or by writing to patrimony@bayswatertransflow.com. The initial correspondence should state the transaction in one line, the vehicles and jurisdictions involved, the stage reached, the principal constraint and the advisers already appointed. Engagement beyond an initial reading of the question proceeds only on written terms.
14. Strategic Takeaways
A sustainable EBITDA conclusion is built from the quality of the underlying records and the economics of the business. It is not created by the size of an add-back schedule. The analyst begins by reconciling the historical financial information, tests whether revenue has been earned and whether related costs have been recorded, examines owner and related-party arrangements, challenges unusual and recurring cost claims, and identifies missing accruals, reserves and capitalised operating costs. Customer wins, losses, acquisitions, disposals and implemented cost actions are then separated into the correct historical or pro forma period.
The resulting figures should be presented transparently: reported EBITDA, diligence-adjusted historical EBITDA, pro forma run-rate EBITDA and forecast EBITDA should not be combined into a single figure without explanation. Every material adjustment should be traceable, evidenced, correctly measured, non-duplicative and connected to the business that will continue after the transaction. Lease accounting, net debt, working capital and the contractual EBITDA definition must be treated consistently with the financing and transaction documents.
For the promoter, the work improves readiness and reduces the risk of a financing process being derailed by avoidable diligence findings. For the investor or lender, it protects valuation and underwriting discipline. For the transaction itself, it provides a defensible basis for deciding how much capital is appropriate, which instrument should be used and what conditions need to be satisfied before execution.
The next step after establishing sustainable EBITDA is to determine how much of that earnings base converts into cash available for interest, tax, maintenance investment, working capital and scheduled principal repayment. A positive EBITDA figure is not the same thing as debt-service capacity. That distinction is examined in Article 16, From EBITDA to Cash Available for Debt Service.
15. References and Further Reading
[1] Travis W. Harms, Mercer Capital, “Quality of Earnings Analysis: What Buyers and Sellers Need to Know About Quality of Earnings Reports,” AIRA Journal, Vol. 37, No. 2 (2024), pp. 8-14. The article discusses the distinction between audit, QoE and projections; categories of earnings adjustments; and the relationship between EBITDA, working capital and capital expenditure. Read the article.
[2] U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission, Division of Corporation Finance, “Non-GAAP Financial Measures: Compliance and Disclosure Interpretations,” last updated 13 December 2022. The interpretations concern the presentation of non-GAAP measures by SEC registrants, including potentially misleading adjustments, recurring operating expenses, consistency between periods and reconciliation. They are cited as a reporting-discipline reference, not as a universal private-credit rule. Read the SEC guidance.
[3] IFRS Foundation, IFRS 15, Revenue from Contracts with Customers. The standard sets out the principles for recognising revenue to depict the transfer of promised goods or services and the consideration to which an entity expects to be entitled. Read the IFRS Foundation overview.
[4] IFRS Foundation, IAS 24, Related Party Disclosures. The standard addresses disclosures intended to draw attention to the possibility that related-party relationships and transactions may affect an entity’s financial position or profit or loss. Read the IFRS Foundation overview.
[5] IFRS Foundation, IAS 37, Provisions, Contingent Liabilities and Contingent Assets. The standard addresses the recognition and measurement of provisions, including obligations whose timing or amount is uncertain. Read the IFRS Foundation overview.
[6] IFRS Foundation, IAS 2, Inventories. The standard addresses inventory cost, measurement at the lower of cost and net realisable value, and recognition of write-downs as expenses. Read the IFRS Foundation overview.
[7] IFRS Foundation, IAS 16, Property, Plant and Equipment. The standard distinguishes day-to-day servicing costs, which are recognised in profit or loss as incurred, from qualifying costs that may be recognised in the carrying amount of an asset. Read the IFRS Foundation overview.
[8] IFRS Foundation, IFRS 16, Leases. The standard establishes the lessee accounting model under which right-of-use assets and lease liabilities are recognised for leases within its scope, subject to specified exemptions. Read the IFRS Foundation overview.
[9] PwC, “Financial Due Diligence.” The overview identifies quality of earnings, net working capital, diligence analytics and transaction closing mechanisms as distinct but connected diligence workstreams. Read the PwC overview.
Research note: External accounting references were reviewed on 17 November 2026. IFRS references are relevant only where the entity reports under IFRS Accounting Standards or the relevant requirements have been adopted in its jurisdiction. Companies reporting under US GAAP or local accounting standards must be assessed under the applicable framework. This article is analytical and educational; it does not reproduce the full text of any accounting standard. The worked company, financial statements, adjustments, multiples and leverage ratios are hypothetical and are not actual transaction data, market quotations or evidence of any capital provider’s willingness to finance a transaction.
16. Institutional and Professional Disclaimer
This article is intended for professional and institutional readers and their advisers. It is provided for general information and analytical discussion only. It does not constitute an audit, assurance engagement, accounting opinion, valuation, credit opinion, investment recommendation, offer, invitation, legal advice, tax advice or regulatory advice. The illustrative company, financial figures, EBITDA adjustments, valuation multiple, leverage ratio and transaction calculations are hypothetical and must not be relied upon as a benchmark for any actual business or financing.
Accounting treatment depends on the applicable reporting framework, the facts and circumstances, and the entity’s accounting policies. A lender’s contractual definition of EBITDA may differ from the analytical measures discussed in this article. Transaction documents may also allocate the same balance-sheet item differently for net debt, working capital and purchase-price purposes. Each company and transaction requires review by its appointed auditors, accountants, legal advisers, tax advisers and other appropriately qualified professionals.
Bayswater Transflow is not a lender, does not deploy balance-sheet capital, does not manage investment funds, does not hold client money and is not authorised by the UK Financial Conduct Authority. Its role in a transaction, where engaged, is governed by separate written terms and must remain within the firm’s applicable legal and regulatory permissions. Any activity requiring an authorised or licensed professional must be undertaken by a party appointed for that purpose under its own permissions. Nothing in this article implies that a capital provider has reviewed, accepted or committed to finance any opportunity, or that a financing outcome can be guaranteed.


